Playing smarter is a must
You know what the biggest difference was in their win over the Raiders and three previous close losses? Against the Raiders, they had only four penalties for 35 yards (including one stupid personal foul on special teams from Keion Crossen). In close losses to the Chiefs, Falcons and Washington – all decided on last-minute field goals – they had a combined 29 penalties for 222 yards.
Throw in an array of wrong pass routes, poor quarterback decisions and a mismanaged clock, and it’s a terrible combination. That didn’t happen against the Raiders, for the most part. They played a smart, clean game. Joe Judge is supposed to be all about discipline. His teams are supposed to be smart and detail-oriented. If they’re not, they won’t win the big games they need. They’ll just continue to throw them away.
Whether it’s Saquon Barkley or someone else, they have to establish the run
They have been a terrible run team all season long, especially if you take out Jones who was their leading rusher until Sunday. Jones’ ability to move definitely helps, but until Devontae Booker’s 99-yard effort against the Raiders, they hadn’t established their running backs as much of a factor – even when Barkley was healthy early in the season.
Booker actually became a factor a week ago in Kansas City (with 125 total yards, though only 60 on the ground). On Sunday, against a strong Raiders front, the Giants could see how effective a running game can be. Jones didn’t have much time for big plays in the passing game. But Booker kept the offense moving.
That will have to continue. And when Barkley’s back, he can’t just be boom-or-bust with his runs. He has to be much more consistent than he’s been. Booker has proven they should work him in when Barkley is back, too.
A big-play threat has to emerge
Remember the excitement and energy everyone felt when Toney had his breakout 10 catch, 189-yard game against the Cowboys? It wasn’t just felt by fans, either. The players felt it, too. He gave them a boost with his high-octane performance, his dazzling catches and the Odell-like way he got out of trouble and turned short passes into big gains.
The Giants aren’t going to survive long with the kind of ground-and-pound game they played against the Raiders, with Jones throwing for only 110 yards. Yes, they need that running game, but this is still a passing league and their air attack can’t just be “managed.” It needs to have a play-making element that it looked like Toney was bringing until he hurt his ankle and, later, his thumb.
Toney is the most likely player to bring that. Golladay was supposed to bring it in a different way too. And Barkley, of course, can be that kind of player as a runner or receiver. One of them needs to become that down the stretch, because if the Giants are going to go on a run towards the playoffs, their anemic offense definitely needs a jolt.