Now Commenting On:

All good things come to an end. Yesterday, longtime Giant DE Justin Tuck decided to take the riches of the West Coast by signing a two year, $11 million deal with the Oakland Raiders.

Should the Giants have kept him?

Tuck says he gave the Giants a chance to match but it obviously wasn't enough.

The Daily News Live panel discusses whether the Giants made a mistake in letting Justin Tuck go sign with the Oakland Raiders.

I personally felt he wold return for maybe two years, $6 million or something along those lines. The Giants would liked to have kept Tuck, but his history of injuries and the down years of 2011 and 2012 kept their offer low.

Your thoughts.....

Tags: New York Giants
Login with Facebook Login with Twitter Login with