Keep Nicks for the remainder of the season and takes their chances in free agency, or trade him and never look back.
Most fans would choose to keep Nicks, but that would prove costly and prevent them from spending that money to improve in the many other areas they need help in.
If they trade Nicks, they can get a mid-round pick and hopefully not waste it like they have the past few years. If Nicks goes the free agent route and leaves, the Giants would be entitled to mid-round compensation but until 2015.
The Daily News Live panel discusses the possibility of the Giants trading wide receiver Hakeem Nicks before the trade deadline.
Let's hear your thoughts on the topic....