He asks the question, if you were in a position to make the trade, would you trade Marc Staal, Derek Stepan, Artem Anisimov and a first round pick for, at least, two years of Shea Weber.
I wrote about this after the hearing and said that I wouldn't trade Staal, Stepan and a first for Weber. Staal brings more value to the Rangers with his contract than Weber would and Stepan has the kind of potential that you don't want to lose. Then you would throw in Anisimov and you lose your second and third line centers, both at cheap and reasonable contracts, but you do get the best defenseman, arguably, in the league.
Why or why not?